Wednesday, June 30, 2010

A Survey

Consider changes that you have had to make in your classroom to accommodate mandatory testing.

  • What aspects of these changes have been helpful to you and your students?
  • What aspects have been difficult?
It may be helpful to make a list of the pros and cons of the new testing requirements; there will likely be some of both. Then compare your list with a colleague’s.

  • Do you agree that there is certain content information that forms the body of cultural literacy necessary for all to know who live in the United States or in any given culture?
  • Do you think today’s focus on content knowledge is helpful in building a stronger base of informed literacy for all students?
  • Do you feel that the way you are now teaching contributes to increased
    intellectual curiosity in your students?
  • Are you able to lead them into the pure joy of learning for its own sake and not simply to perform well on a test?
  • Finally, think about your own situation.
  • When was the last time you personally learned something new just for the fun of it?
  • Has your love of learning increased or diminished over the past years?
    Can you identify the causes?
Reflect again on your early schooling when you were gaining information by reading in various subject areas. What sparked your interest or made you want to know more? Did you have any difficulty reading for information? Nothing derails intellectual curiosity more thoroughly than a reading problem. If you did not struggle with reading difficulties, how did you feel about those who did? Our attitudes toward those who have educational challenges are usually formed in elementary school. The challenge of struggling learners remains very much with us today. Does their lack of progress fuel frustration for you?

The Pressures Are Real

In reality, many in school settings today feel the pressure of the “cooker.” We are in a global race, and our educational systems are under scrutiny by the rest of the world. America has always been its own worst critic, and our perceptions of our fragile educational system have fired international criticism. Our global “standings” have taken on political ramifications, resulting in demoralized teachers and forcing many to leave this time-honored profession. Some teachers have recently made these comments:

‘‘I am retiring early primarily due to the manner in which I am
forced to teach and assess.’’ ‘‘I don’t teach much reading anymore: I am too busy testing children.’’ ‘‘We feel we are fleeing a sinking ship, after giving our entire lives to our students and our profession.’’ ‘‘It is a sad way to end a career.’’

The pressures have invaded the classrooms and challenged the status quo. Both methods and methodologies are in question, so that teacher confidence and competence have suffered. As the rest of the world looks on, the internal pressures to perform continue to build.

Yet America still leads the world in two important qualities formed in the schools of our nation: creativity and innovation. I was recently on a train in India sitting opposite two professors from South Korea. In our conversation, they remarked that most foreign students long to attend American universities simply because they encourage student debate, are open to fresh new ideas, and are not overly focused on test scores. If this is true at the university level, an important question to be asked is, “What is happening in our elementary and secondary schools?”

Innovation, a blending of intellect and imagination, has truly catapulted and sustained America’s place as a dominant economic force in the global economy. But China and India are on the move in the areas of technology and manufacturing. A great book that explains this phenomenon is The Elephant and the Dragon by Robyn Meredith (2007). China is turning out an abundance of engineers, and India is excelling in technology. But the Chinese themselves have noted that no one from their country has yet won the Nobel Prize. If we downplay innovation and creative thinking at the expense of performing well on standardized tests, we will not only lose our creative teachers but also lose our credibility as a superpower.

Reflect for a moment on this quote (Caine and Caine, 1991):

‘‘Meaningful learning is essentially creative. All students must be given permission to transcend the insights of their teachers.’’

LET’S GET PERSONAL

Have you sensed rising pressure and stress as you prepare students for tests? It is important to remember that test-taking has always been a stress producer for students and teachers alike. I expect that back in 1952 my teacher, Miss Scott, stressed out on testing days.

A New Life

In 1952, my family returned from England to the United States, where I was eager to begin fourth grade in the small town of Bridgeville, Delaware (population 3,500). My father was now out of the military and had returned to his hometown to help my grandfather on the family farm. It was Labor Day, and the roadside market that they ran was particularly busy, so I was amusing myself by playing on the tractor that was standing idle in the field. Before I knew what happened, I had slid from the smooth surface of the tractor’s body where I was relaxing on my stomach and slammed hard onto the ground, breaking my arm in two places.

Being a very religious child (even though I had not seen Jesus under the drape at school in England!), I quickly ran up to the house, fell on my knees, and in a wild, tearful prayer asked God to help me! There was no immediate evidence of such assistance, but I marched bravely to the market and fearfully told my parents about my mishap. They were not too pleased to have to take me to the hospital that day, the busiest of the year. Looking back now, I know it was not a hard-hearted response but a fearful one. We were counting on the income from the sale of our produce.

The moments of my life surged like a pulse, and my memories of them shape me still. The idea of having to walk into a new school with a cast on my arm kept me awake and in tears the night before. Any sense of joy in going to school was quickly overshadowed by a deep insecurity and sadness because of my accident. Would I be laughed at or teased? I was a year younger and smaller than my peers, having begun school in England at the age of four, and that made me even more vulnerable. So I began fourth grade with a cast on my right arm, forcing me to write with my left. This seemed to place me in a very precarious academic position. I not only had to adjust to a very different school culture than the one I had just left but also spoke with a peculiar English accent, and my handwriting looked like I had subnormal intelligence. My teacher, Miss Scott, had certain very proper ways of running a classroom, and never having encountered a child who had been schooled in England before, was not quite sure what to do with me. In the end, I was givenan F in handwriting, and was sent off to the fifth grade in the hopes I could do better.

In addition to these humbling experiences, my father and mother were going through the postwar stresses thatmany families had in those days, so life at home became quite noisy and argumentative. I withdrew more and more into a private world that I could order, and I brought my younger brother, Jackie, along with me. On one memorable occasion, there was a fierce argument going on in the kitchen, then a terrific bang. The pressure cooker had exploded and pieces of macaroni hung everywhere. Jackie and I looked on in wonder asMom and Dad trembled at their good fortune that the lid, which had made a great hole in the ceiling, had not fallen on their heads!

Sunday, June 27, 2010

Prepare the Lesson

But before revealing the text on the screen ask, “Jan, what do you know about frogs?” Don’t wait for a hand; ask a specific student and then another. “Ed, do you have more you could add?” “Can you share a personal experience you have had with a frog?” “Describe a frog. In what scientific category could you put a frog? Why? What else would go in that category? What would not?” Explore knowledge through oral language. You are helping students make connections through your questioning.

Project the Text of the Fable

After projecting the text ask, “What do you see here?” Many will want to get right into the content, but focus them with a question such as, “Can you describe the page?” Enlist the response, “A title and a short paragraph.” Ask, “Is the author listed?” “Do you think you might know who the author is?” Aesop should be part of a student’s vocabulary of cultural literacy. Then, “What is a fable?” Lead students by helping them restate their answers to reach a clear, concise definition. Check a dictionary prior to the lesson for clear, specific terminology.

Depending on your class, have the passage read silently or orally and then begin a group discussion on what lesson the fable teaches. You may need to provide some hints. As a class, see if you can come up with ideas. Some examples might be:

  • Look before you leap.
  • Haste makes waste.
  • Think before you rush into something new.
Build Intelligence

Select one of the options and write it on the board after developing it collaboratively as a whole group. This is high-level abstract reasoning. Getting students to talk about the lesson of the fable challenges them to stretch their intellectual powers. And yours. Tell them that.

Ask: “What does this passage teach us about intelligence? How intelligent was the first frog? The second? Were they both able to learn from past experiences? What behavior of the second frog made you think he was intelligent? Can you think of an example from your own life when you were doing something similar to what the frogs did?” Be prepared to share an example from your childhood experience. Students love to hear your stories. This personalization of the fable stretches the learning into a different context, developing cognitive strengths that transfer to other learning.

These suggestions are specifically designed to build intellectual competency, and because they are intended to be answered orally by students, they have the power to direct meaningful thought processes. The power of oral language will be explored later.

Develop Cognitive Competence

As you probe student thinking through open-ended questions, you will
begin to see new cognitive skills emerge. Connecting to students’ prior
experience is always a great place to start. Engage them immediately with
what they already know or have personally experienced. Keep the dialogue
fun, light, and entertaining. This is a great time for you to share your frog
experiences!

Having your students describe the layout or format of the page in clear and precise language helps direct efficient thinking processes and evolves into the great skill of being able to predict tasks by the layout of the page, even before reading the directions. When students begin to anticipate the task based on the page format, it means they are being trained in observation skills that will eventually become internalized and automatic. So, for any new task begin with the question, “What do you see on this page?” Work toward a clear, succinct verbal response. For example: “There are no blanks on this page and no explicit instructions, so I am going to have to infer some things based on the content of the paragraph.”

The ability to put words into categories is an important cognitive skill. Noting likenesses and differences refines intellectual and verbal abilities. In addition, students benefit greatly by hearing their peers express their knowledge. Even more intellectually challenging is the ability to summarize and state a lesson the fable teaches. Have your students work in pairs in future sessions to encourage oral exploration of possibilities. Select a sentence and write it on the board to crystallize the activity. For example, you or a student may write:

Being intelligent and wise means being able to think both backwards to what
happened before and forward to what might happen.

Again, the skill of a master teacher in the learning process provides the structure your students need to direct their own learning. Through your questioning, you are teaching them how to learn. Then the “what,” or content, will come more easily. You are building fluid, intellectual competence. As you purpose to raise your expectations above your students’ actual levels of performance, you will be amazed at the hidden propensities that emerge. Begin by:

  • Engaging the quiet ones
  • Not calling on the first hand you see
  • Moving strategically around the room
  • Helping students restate their weak verbal responses
  • Being one of the learners
  • Setting appropriate challenges
  • Modeling your own love of learning
  • Building respect for all sincere responses.
REFLECTION

We have begun to infuse some new ideas into the intelligence dilemma. Are you beginning to wonder in your mind and heart if in your classroom in this year you might actually be able to change your students’ abilities to think, reason, remember, and reflect? And to do the same with your own? As teachers, we are not called to simply build fact upon fact; instead, we have the great privilege of renovating the mind’s architecture—in particular, constructing a skylight, a window in those man-made ceilings.

Teaching is both art and science. As you become more confident and competent in your ability to get students talking in meaningful ways to you and to each other, you will begin to equip them with tools that will keep getting better and better. The secret will be unwrapped in the concepts of cognitive modifiability and mediated learning. We will examine both in the next chapter.

Starting School

The year was 1949, and my father had just received military orders to Lakenheath Air Force Base in central England following World War II. Postwar England was a sad and dreary place. It seemed the hearts of the people had been damaged beyond the devastation of the countryside. Ration cards restricted the purchase of many staples, including sugar, butter, and eggs. The war had taken a terrible toll on the country. When we arrived there from America, we could feel the misery. We had come to help.

From my five-year-old perspective, the long, dark days, damp woolen uniforms, meager rations, and never-ending split pea soup for lunch had only a minimal negative impact on my first school experiences. For I was going to school, an event I had yearned for since my earliest memories. I was, as my mother said, ‘‘wired for it.’’ From the first I was clamorous to learn and could hardly contain the wonder of books and desks and teachers.

I began my formal schooling in a very strict parochial school in a little village called Bury St. Edmonds. The nuns were unbending in their discipline. There was certainly no foolishness allowed and definitely no fun. I have few memories of lessons learned or favorite teachers, yet it was here, I believe, that my desire to become a teacher was formed. Maybe it had something to do with the discipline and work ethic or the childlike wonder of learning for its own sake without the frills. Learning to read was one of my greatest joys because it opened to my curious mind whole new worlds.My natural quest for adventure found an outlet in learning, and I soaked it in like a sponge.

However, my curiosity and adventurous spirit got the better of me one day when I climbed up on the altar in the church to see if Jesus really was under that draped chalice as the nuns said he was. I did not see him. Even the severe discipline of Sister Paul Mary did not deter my quest for knowledge. Was I intelligent? I think intellectually curious would be a better description. In any case, my first three years of schooling in England set me on a course of learning for life and helped form many of my beliefs about education. The formation of my intellectual curiosity happened despite the hardships. I did not need worksheets, colorful pages, stars for performance, or grades that affirmed my competence. I had an innate joy in learning for its own sake. As I reflect on the model of the three-story intellect, I see that I yearned for more than just the facts. Staying on the first floor held no appeal. I wanted the skylight.

Reflect for a moment on your early school experiences. Those events helped shape your perceptions of your abilities and aptitudes. They define for you the beginning understandings of your intellectual abilities, your desire to learn, and your attitudes toward other learners. In fact, they may help explain why you became a teacher. As educators, it is helpful for us to examine the circumstances of our lives that led us into this profession. Each of us comes to it with a belief system shaped through personal experiences.

Let’s Get Personal

Consider your classroom:

  • Do you see your students in categories?
  • Are the bright ones in the front row (literally or figuratively)?
  • In contrast, are the slower ones in the back?
  • What about those average learners? You may be really surprised to learn that some in the back row actually have an ability to think more abstractly and make more meaningful connections than those who succeed so well in memorizing the school subjects.
Consider your teaching style:

  • Do you tend to lower your expectations to a student’s curren level of functioning?
  • Do you call on the first hand that is up to keep the lesson moving?
  • Do you do most of the talking during a school day? Do you
  • consider memorization the goal for mastery of a concept?
Consider your personal level of confidence and competence:
  • Do you think you are a good teacher?
  • Are you confident that all students in your class are learning?
  • Do you give preferential treatment to the bright students who
  • learn easily?
  • Are struggling learners a chore or a welcome challenge?
  • Do you believe your own thinking and learning are modifiable?

The Root of Intelligence

To define intelligence we must first consider the theories and the research done by the individuals who proposed the theories. We have already examined three prominent ones. In addition, the word itself should be analyzed. The root of the word intelligence is intellegere, Latin for “to understand.” Intelligence implies a general mental capacity that varies from person to person and fluctuates over a lifespan. Different individuals have particular propensities or deficits in the areas of reasoning, planning, problem solving, comprehending abstract ideas, and learning from experience. Innate abilities or disabilities in these areas, however, should never be seen as permanent or unmodifiable. All learners can improve their ability to recognize connections as well as develop the capacity to think strategically, thereby laying the groundwork for new knowledge.

Clearly, individuals vary in their ability to understand complex ideas, to adapt effectively to their environments, to engage in different kinds of reasoning, and to overcome obstacles by creative thought. In addition, a given individual’s intellectual performance will vary greatly on any given day and when judged by different criteria. Here is one simple definition that incorporates many of the qualities mentioned:

Intelligence is the ability to recognize and make connections.

This simple definition is extremely relevant to us as we explore learning how to learn in a classroom setting. It may even represent a benchmark for you and your students. How well do you recognize and make connections? Can you teach this skill to your students to enhance their intellectual competency?

Intellectual Potential?

If you ever took an IQ test, you were placed in a category that perhaps “boxed you in” for life. You may have believed that your intellectual potential was measured, when actually your score was merely a predictor of how well you would do in school. The inventors of IQ tests reportedly never believed they were measuring fixed intelligence, yet in practice many educators have translated the scores into biological realities that can never change. Binet, the author of one of the first intelligence tests, is reported to have said, “If it were not possible to change intelligence, why measure it in the first place?” (cited in Campioni, 1989, p. 155).

For example, one look at a child with Down’s syndrome assures many that any attempt to improve on this child’s intellectual functioning would be futile. Yet how many enlightened teachers would declare, “Chromosomes do not have the last word” (Feuerstein, 2006). Many children who have Down’s syndrome today are achieving far more than anyone believed they could fifty years ago. Perhaps the most important quality of intelligence that Feuerstein’s mosaic theory presents is modifiability—that is, the belief that intelligence is not constant or static, but wonderfully open to constructive change for all learners throughout a lifetime.

Mediated Learning

As we enter the arena of intellectual dynamic unpredictability, or the realization that learning is not a lockstep, highly predictable process, we learn to expect change in our students. Embracing the “mosaic model” means that the teacher should believe in the reversibility of poor academic performance, not doubt it. Intellectual skills can be developed by both teachers and students. However, such change does not happen by chance or without understanding the mediator’s role in the process.

The good news for teachers is that all minds can be stretched, inherent abilities unmasked, and thought processes developed—even our own! The secret lies in unwrapping the amazing concept of mediated learning. Mediated learning, in brief, relies on the guidance of an adult, whose role is to help interpret the complex world of input from the environment so that the child can focus, frame, and consider relationships. An extra bonus is that in the process of teaching a child to learn, the teacher too becomes better able to learn and think and make those all important connections. We will discuss mediated learning in more detail in the next chapter.